'Bitter Harvest' reduces Ukrainian tragedy to melodramatic mush

The Holodomor -- an early 1930s famine in which millions of people in Ukraine are said to have died when their foodstuffs were confiscated by the Soviet government under Joseph Stalin -- could have made for a tale of great, stirring tragedy on the silver...

'Bitter Harvest' reduces Ukrainian tragedy to melodramatic mush

The Holodomor -- an early 1930s famine in which millions of people in Ukraine are said to have died when their foodstuffs were confiscated by the Soviet government under Joseph Stalin -- could have made for a tale of great, stirring tragedy on the silver screen. "Bitter Harvest," alas, is not that movie. Maudlin, heavy-handed and histrionic when a more subdued touch would have sufficed, the below-made-for-TV-caliber drama about the historical event is a cartoonish and unengaging telling of an undeniable tragedy.

Whether the Holodomor resulted from a policy of systemic genocide, as is the official position of Ukraine and many other governments, or was a terrible situation that nevertheless fails to meet the definition of deliberate mass murder, as others have characterized it, is a matter for U.N. diplomats and historians to argue about. In the view of "Bitter Harvest" filmmaker George Mendeluk, a TV director who cut his feature-filmmaking teeth on such classics as "Amber Alert: Terror on the Highway" and "12 Hours to Live," the scenario is not just unambiguous, but black and white.

"Bitter Harvest"

Stalin (Gary Oliver) is depicted as a villain straight out of a black-and-white serial from 100 years ago, with his evil henchman, the commissar Sergei (Tamer Hassan), depicted as a brutish caricature of heartlessness. When the commissar and his Bolshevik enforcers descend upon a Ukrainian farming village, for instance, trampling on horseback over an innocent woman making her way with a loaf of bread, the camera cuts to an unsubtle and overly symbolic shot: the broken and blood-spattered loaf, lying by the side of the road.

Mendeluk never misses an opportunity to insult the intelligence of the audience, whether it's by an early sequence of two horses -- presumably representing Russia and Ukraine, then part of the Soviet Union -- rearing up in a slow-motion confrontation, or a close-up shot of a Ukrainian resistance fighter's eyeglasses, lying smashed on the pavement.

The movie centers on Yuri (Max Irons), a young painter who becomes radicalized when his village is enslaved by Sergei, who forces Yuri's neighbors into a program of what was known as agricultural "collectivization," with the harvest of Ukrainian farmers carted off to feed Russians. Any independent farmer who resisted was labeled a "kulak" -- an enemy of the Communist state -- and sometimes killed.

Although there is a tepid love story between Yuri and his childhood sweetheart, Natalka (Samantha Barks), simmering in the background, the main narrative of "Bitter Harvest" is one of armed struggle by kulaks and their sympathizers. Too often, however, the action is characterized less by revolutionary steel than melodramatic mush. Natalka, for example, toys with the idea of prostitution to feed her family. And when a Ukrainian man kills himself in despair, a Soviet soldier offers this snarky toast, delivered with the same lack of subtlety that characterizes the rest of the script (by Richard Bachynsky Hoover): "To all Ukrainian nationals, may they continue to save us ammunition."

There ought to be no lack of firepower in telling this shameful tale. Too often, however, "Bitter Harvest" is guilty of overkill.

Our editors found this article on this site using Google and regenerated it for our readers.

You need to login to comment.

Please register or login.

RELATED NEWS