Those who falsify vaccination cards cannot hope for impunity in the future. If an accused cannot be found guilty of falsifying health certificates, the offense of document falsification can be used. The background to the judgment is a case in Hamburg.
According to a fundamental decision by the Federal Court of Justice (BGH), counterfeiters of corona vaccination cards cannot hope for impunity because of a legal loophole. If an accused cannot be found guilty of falsifying health certificates, a conviction for falsification of documents can still be considered, the BGH ruled.
With this judgment, the 5th Criminal Senate closed an alleged criminal liability gap. The decision relates to the legal situation that applied until November 2021. After that, the penal code was changed. The judgment is based on a case from Hamburg. The regional court there had acquitted a man of allegations of document forgery who had issued false vaccination certificates in nine cases. The accused entered alleged corona vaccinations in vaccination cards and provided them with false stamps and signatures. The regional court had assumed that the man had not made himself a criminal offense for falsifying health certificates.
Although there was already a law criminalizing such counterfeiting, it was only punished if it was presented to authorities or insurance companies. Cases in which the forged document was shown to a pharmacy for a digital vaccination certificate or in the catering trade were left out. At the same time, from the point of view of the regional court, a conviction for forgery of documents was generally not possible because the special regulation on health certificates had a so-called blocking effect. The BGH has now denied this blocking effect. The Hamburg Regional Court will now have to re-examine whether the accused should be convicted of forgery.
