Breaking News         Latest US News              New York News              Fx Tribune

Benefits of Having an Immigration Lawyer Representing You
the Treasury department estimates that those affected by the tax of the mortgage you can claim up to 5,000 million we Can call to mobilize if there is a fai

Absolute division of the Supreme court by the judgment of the mortgages: nine positions stated, five in favor of the bank and four against

the Treasury department estimates that those affected by the tax of the mortgage you can claim up to 5,000 million we Can call to mobilize if there is a fai

Absolute division of the Supreme court by the judgment of the mortgages: nine positions stated, five in favor of the bank and four against

the Treasury department estimates that those affected by the tax of the mortgage you can claim up to 5,000 million

we Can call to mobilize if there is a failure in favor of banking

The Government tries to curb the retroactive claims

The Supreme Court ruled Monday that the fast-track to settle the disagreements about who should pay the tax on mortgages: limited to ratify the novelty of jurisprudence agreed in the judgment of the specialized Section on taxes without going to the merits of the case.

That proposal was rejected by the Full of the Room of the Contentious-Administrative, which preferred to go ahead and study the three resources that I had on the table. This was done, and to the last hour of the afternoon, barely a third of the judges had been pronounced, so that the deliberation will continue this Tuesday and there is nothing to guarantee that today is resolved.

The first to expose their position were the speakers of the resources, identical to those that led two weeks ago to the Second Section to change in the law and to establish that the tax is the responsibility of the banks.

The interventions of Nicholas Maurandi (president of the Section) and Jose Navarro advocated for moving forward with what they themselves signed in that sentence is key. Then they began to speak the rest of the magistrates, in the reverse order of their date of access to the Supreme. Intervened seven, which was enough to reflect the situation in the Hall: complete division. Of the nine positions stated, four supported the change of case-law, while five were rejected.

Sources of the court recognized that in the debates, however, the voltage at which the Third Chamber has been installed since the release of the judgment and its president agreed to discuss again the issue in the Plenary. This measure was discussed for various reasons. Because he questioned the Section that had issued the judgment, because prolonging the uncertainty about who should pay, and because it seemed to be cediéndose to the pressures of the banks.

At the Plenary session of Monday not challenged the legality of the call by Luis María Díez-Picazo. However, one of the speakers of the judgment questioned himself proposed to endorse the resolution almost automatically. Both by the own reasoning of the judgment-essentially, the bank is the one that benefited from the mortgage is registered - as by various procedural aspects. For example, the value of the case-law of a section is the same as that of the Full, or that there is a principle of trust of citizens in keeping a decision as notified and public.

Several justices suggested that this proposal meant that, in the background, questioning the call of the Full. Finally it was rejected by 20 votes to eight, which led to the afternoon will be addressed as resources directly.

On the day this Tuesday, and once all the judges have exposed your seem, it will try to bring their positions closer. Various sources of the court consider a decision that reflects the court split in half, it would be wrong for the Supreme and a confusing message to the markets.

The agreement does not seem easy, seen that the postures are not even two, but three: (1) return to the classical measure of the tax is paid by the client, (2) maintain the change of case-law stating expressly that the novelty will only apply to future situations, without any retroactivity; and (3) to ratify that the bank is paying but without the mention of retroactivity, thereby leaving the margin of four years of claims tax to the Treasury.

The decision rests with 28 judges. One of the three members of the board absent from the Full has abstained because a family member has a protected housing in Rivas-Vaciamadrid, precisely the municipality that has submitted the resources.

According to the criteria of

Learn more

Publish Date : 08 Kasım 2018 Perşembe 08:01

Breaking News Headlines

What To Do To Ensure Comprehensive Safety On Your Devices
What To Do To Ensure Comprehensive Safety On Your Devices
Santiago de Chile and New York, two new destinations of Level from Barcelona
Santiago de Chile and New York, two new destinations of Level from Barcelona
The Valencian Community holds the pull of the 'all inclusive' in Turkey
The Valencian Community holds the pull of the 'all inclusive' in Turkey
New round of strikes at Amazon: unions call for eight-day strike at Christmas
New round of strikes at Amazon: unions call for eight-day strike at Christmas
The Bank of Spain to qualify the number of lawsuits as a risk relevant for Spanish entities
The Bank of Spain to qualify the number of lawsuits as a risk relevant for Spanish entities
The Eurogroup, seamless front to Italy
The Eurogroup, seamless front to Italy
The Government proposes that the self-employed raise another "disproportionate" contributions: 260 euros per year
The Government proposes that the self-employed raise another
The employer's charge against the budgets of the Generalitat: income "optimistic" and "unattainable"
The employer's charge against the budgets of the Generalitat: income
The Government communicates the final closure of the oil field most ancient of Spain
The Government communicates the final closure of the oil field most ancient of Spain
Absolute division of the Supreme court by the judgment of the mortgages: nine positions stated, five in favor of the bank and four against
Absolute division of the Supreme court by the judgment of the mortgages: nine positions stated, five in favor of the bank and four against
The Best Ashes-Winning England Performances
The Best Ashes-Winning England Performances
Spain falls to the position 30 in the ranking of 'Doing Business' ease of business
Spain falls to the position 30 in the ranking of 'Doing Business' ease of business
POLLS Results ALL
Who is the most powerful actor in Syria

Front Pages
  • The Sun
NEWS ARCHIVES